Salt Water vs. Chlorine: Costs, Maintenance & Water Feel for Orange County Pools (2025 Guide)

Is salt water really better than chlorine? Salt water pools still sanitize water using chlorine — the salt system uses electrolysis to convert dissolved salt into free chlorine. That means you still need balanced chemistry, but the water often feels smoother and smells less like chloramines. Converting to salt water is popular in Orange County (OC) because we swim year‑round; this guide compares salt systems vs. traditional chlorine for costs, maintenance, and water feel so you can decide if a conversion makes sense for your pool.

Quick take: which is better?

Salt systems cost more up front but can simplify weekly maintenance. A salt chlorinator generates a steady supply of free chlorine, so you no longer buy and store liquid or tablet chlorine. Many pool owners appreciate the softer feel of salt water and less of the “pool smell.” However, you still need to test and balance pH, alkalinity and cyanuric acid, and you’ll eventually replace the salt cell. Traditional chlorine systems cost less initially and work well for all pool surfaces; they may be a better fit if you seldom swim or have surfaces that don’t tolerate salt well.

How a salt system sanitizes water

A saltwater pool uses a salt chlorinator (also called a salt cell) installed in your plumbing. As pool water flows through, an electrical current splits salt (sodium chloride) into sodium and chlorine gas, which dissolves as hypochlorous acid to sanitize the water. Because chlorine is generated continuously, the water has fewer chloramine by‑products — the compounds that cause red eyes and strong chlorine smell.

Ideal salt range and water chemistry

Most systems run best between 2,700–3,400 ppm of salt. That is only about one‑tenth the salt of seawater (30,000–35,000 ppm), so the water doesn’t taste noticeably salty. To protect your equipment:

  • pH: Keep pH between 7.4–7.6.

  • Free Chlorine: 1–3 ppm.

  • Total Alkalinity: 80–120 ppm.

  • Calcium Hardness: 200–400 ppm.

  • Cyanuric Acid (stabilizer): 30–50 ppm.

Regularly test and adjust these levels, even with a salt system.

Real‑world costs in Orange County

Converting to salt water involves both one‑time and ongoing expenses:

  • Equipment and installation: A salt chlorinator, control board and installation typically cost $1,500–$2,500. The price depends on pool size, plumbing complexity and equipment brand.

  • Ongoing costs: Your cell uses electricity and may require slightly more pump run‑time. You’ll add salt initially (often 6–10 bags) and top up occasionally after backwashing or heavy rain. Electricity costs are modest, but salt cells do wear out.

  • Cell replacement: A salt cell lasts 3–7 years; replacement cells cost $300–$600. When the control board and cell need replacement together, expect $1,200–$2,000.

By comparison, a traditional chlorine pool avoids these upfront costs but requires ongoing purchase of chlorine tablets or liquid and occasional shock. Depending on chemical prices and pool size, costs may be similar over several years.

Maintenance: what changes and what doesn’t

With a salt system, you still need to maintain balanced water. Here’s what stays the same and what changes:

  • Weekly: Test free chlorine, pH and alkalinity. Adjust as needed. Inspect the salt chlorinator’s control panel for alerts.

  • Monthly: Check salt level, calcium hardness and cyanuric acid. Add salt if needed to stay within the 2,700–3,400 ppm range.

  • Cell cleaning: Inspect the cell every 2–3 months. If you see scale, soak it in a mild acid solution for 15–20 minutes and rinse thoroughly. Don’t over‑clean; this can shorten cell life.

  • Balancing chemicals: You still adjust pH and alkalinity regularly. Salt systems tend to raise pH slightly, so you may use more acid.

Water feel and user experience

Many people appreciate the silky feel of salt water. Because the system maintains steady chlorine levels, there’s less of the strong smell associated with adding large doses of chlorine manually. Eyes and skin often feel less irritated. However, you won’t float like in the ocean; the salt concentration is much lower.

Corrosion and equipment concerns

Pool industry warnings about salt water usually refer to seawater levels (over 25,000 ppm). At normal pool salinity, most modern pumps, filters and chlorinators are compatible. However, salt water is mildly corrosive to some metals and natural stones:

  • Heaters and metal components: Make sure your heater has a cupro‑nickel heat exchanger and that your pool’s bonding and grounding are up to code. Balanced water chemistry helps prevent corrosion.

  • Stone coping and decks: Porous natural stones can show efflorescence or spalling. Seal stone surfaces and rinse after splashing to minimize damage.

  • Surfaces: Vinyl and fiberglass pools handle salt well. Plaster pools are also generally fine; just maintain proper chemistry.

Orange County specifics

OC’s mild climate means year‑round swimming and minimal winterization. Hard water can increase scaling risk, so keep calcium hardness near the lower end (200 ppm) and consider using a scale inhibitor. Because we don’t fully “close” pools, a salt system can maintain chlorine production all winter at a lower output level.

Bottom line: should you convert?

If you value a softer feel and simplified daily maintenance and are comfortable with a higher upfront cost, a salt system can be a worthwhile upgrade. It’s important to size the system correctly and plan for eventual cell replacement. If your pool uses delicate stone or metal features, or if you rarely swim, traditional chlorine might be simpler and less expensive.

For a personalized evaluation and quote in Orange County, contact our team at Sun Coast Pools & Spa — we’re an authorized Davey distributor and can recommend the right system for your pool.

Scroll to Top